The best mysteries on Prime Video

303 mystery titles are streaming on Prime Video in the US. These are the top 20 by score, rebuilt every day from the live catalogue, so nothing here has already left.

Supernatural poster

Top pick

Supernatural (2005)

BN 86.1Series

When they were boys, Sam and Dean Winchester lost their mother to a mysterious and demonic supernatural force. Subsequently, their father raised them to be soldiers. He taught them about the paranormal evil that lives in the dark corners…

86Supernatural (2005) posterSupernatural2005 · Series85Criminal Minds (2005) posterCriminal Minds2005 · Series84American Horror Story (2011) posterAmerican Horror Story2011 · Series83Death Note (2006) posterDeath Note2006 · Series83Person of Interest (2011) posterPerson of Interest2011 · Series82The Originals (2013) posterThe Originals2013 · Series81Slow Horses (2022) posterSlow Horses2022 · Series81Memento (2000) posterMemento2000 · Film80Batman: The Animated Series (1992) posterBatman: The Animated Series1992 · Series80Over the Garden Wall (2014) posterOver the Garden Wall2014 · Series80Grimm (2011) posterGrimm2011 · Series79The Thing (1982) posterThe Thing1982 · Film78Fringe (2008) posterFringe2008 · Series78Charmed (1998) posterCharmed1998 · Series77Donnie Darko (2001) posterDonnie Darko2001 · Film75The Sheep Detectives (2026) posterThe Sheep Detectives2026 · Film74Anatomy of a Murder (1959) posterAnatomy of a Murder1959 · Film74The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2009) posterThe Girl with the Dragon Tattoo2009 · Film

Best mystery movies on Prime Video

#TitleBNIMDbRTRuntime
1Memento (2000)81n/an/a1h 53m
2The Thing (1982)79.4n/an/a1h 49m
3Donnie Darko (2001)77n/an/a1h 54m
4The Sheep Detectives (2026)75.1n/an/a1h 49m
5Anatomy of a Murder (1959)73.8n/an/a2h 41m
6The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2009)73.7n/an/a2h 32m
7Contact (1997)73.5n/an/a2h 30m
8The Name of the Rose (1986)73.4n/an/a2h 10m
9Charade (1963)73.4n/an/a1h 53m
10Hereditary (2018)72.5n/an/a2h 8m
11Eastern Promises (2007)72.4n/an/a1h 40m
12The Body (2012)72.3n/an/a1h 47m
13Laura (1944)72.1n/an/a1h 28m
14Exhuma (2024)71.9n/an/a2h 14m
15Limitless (2011)71.7n/an/a1h 46m

Best mystery series on Prime Video

#TitleBNIMDbRTRuntime
1Supernatural (2005)86.1n/an/a45m
2Criminal Minds (2005)85.1n/an/an/a
3American Horror Story (2011)84.3n/an/an/a
4Death Note (2006)83.3n/an/a22m
5Person of Interest (2011)82.7n/an/an/a
6The Originals (2013)82n/an/a45m
7Slow Horses (2022)81.1n/an/an/a
8Batman: The Animated Series (1992)79.8n/an/an/a
9Over the Garden Wall (2014)79.7n/an/a12m
10Grimm (2011)79.5n/an/a42m
11Fringe (2008)77.9n/an/an/a
12Charmed (1998)77.8n/an/an/a

Recently added mystery on Prime Video

Questions about mystery on Prime Video

What is the best mystery movie on Prime Video?

Memento (2000) is the highest-scoring mystery movie on Prime Video right now, at 81/100 on our blend of critic and audience ratings.

What is the best mystery series on Prime Video?

Supernatural leads Prime Video's mystery series at 86.1/100.

How many mysteries are on Prime Video?

We count 303 mystery titles on Prime Video in the US, checked against the live catalogue every day.

What mystery titles were just added to Prime Video?

Recent arrivals include Slow Horses, Yellowjackets, Broadchurch, Place of Execution.

More on Prime Video

Mysteries on other services