The best mysteries on Hulu

199 mystery titles are streaming on Hulu in the US. These are the top 20 by score, rebuilt every day from the live catalogue, so nothing here has already left.

The Mentalist poster

Top pick

The Mentalist (2008)

BN 86Series

Patrick Jane, a former celebrity psychic medium, uses his razor sharp skills of observation and expertise at "reading" people to solve serious crimes with the California Bureau of Investigation.

86The Mentalist (2008) posterThe Mentalist2008 · Series85Criminal Minds (2005) posterCriminal Minds2005 · Series84American Horror Story (2011) posterAmerican Horror Story2011 · Series83Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999) posterLaw & Order: Special Victims Unit1999 · Series83Death Note (2006) posterDeath Note2006 · Series83Sherlock (2010) posterSherlock2010 · Series81Memento (2000) posterMemento2000 · Film81WandaVision (2021) posterWandaVision2021 · Series81The X-Files (1993) posterThe X-Files1993 · Series80Over the Garden Wall (2014) posterOver the Garden Wall2014 · Series79Only Murders in the Building (2021) posterOnly Murders in the Building2021 · Series78Fringe (2008) posterFringe2008 · Series78Lost (2004) posterLost2004 · Series73Where the Crawdads Sing (2022) posterWhere the Crawdads Sing2022 · Film73Hereditary (2018) posterHereditary2018 · Film71Missing (2023) posterMissing2023 · Film70The Accountant² (2025) posterThe Accountant²2025 · Film70It Was Just an Accident (2025) posterIt Was Just an Accident2025 · Film

Best mystery movies on Hulu

#TitleBNIMDbRTRuntime
1Memento (2000)81n/an/a1h 53m
2Where the Crawdads Sing (2022)72.9n/an/a2h 6m
3Hereditary (2018)72.5n/an/a2h 8m
4Missing (2023)71.3n/an/a1h 51m
5The Accountant² (2025)69.8n/an/a2h 13m
6It Was Just an Accident (2025)69.7n/an/a1h 43m
7Barbarian (2022)68.7n/an/a1h 43m
8Uncharted (2022)68.5n/an/a1h 56m
9Wicked Little Letters (2024)68.5n/an/a1h 40m
10The Bob's Burgers Movie (2022)68.4n/an/a1h 42m
11No Exit (2022)68.1n/an/a1h 36m
12The Home (2025)68.1n/an/a1h 35m
13Inspector Sun and the Curse of the Black Widow (2022)67.9n/an/a1h 28m
14Psycho Killer (2026)67.8n/an/a1h 31m
15Sleep (2023)67.8n/an/a1h 34m

Best mystery series on Hulu

#TitleBNIMDbRTRuntime
1The Mentalist (2008)86n/an/an/a
2Criminal Minds (2005)85.1n/an/an/a
3American Horror Story (2011)84.3n/an/an/a
4Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999)83.3n/an/an/a
5Death Note (2006)83.3n/an/a22m
6Sherlock (2010)82.9n/an/a1h 30m
7WandaVision (2021)81n/an/an/a
8The X-Files (1993)80.7n/an/an/a
9Over the Garden Wall (2014)79.7n/an/a12m
10Only Murders in the Building (2021)79.1n/an/an/a
11Fringe (2008)77.9n/an/an/a
12Lost (2004)77.8n/an/an/a

Recently added mystery on Hulu

Questions about mystery on Hulu

What is the best mystery movie on Hulu?

Memento (2000) is the highest-scoring mystery movie on Hulu right now, at 81/100 on our blend of critic and audience ratings.

What is the best mystery series on Hulu?

The Mentalist leads Hulu's mystery series at 86/100.

How many mysteries are on Hulu?

We count 199 mystery titles on Hulu in the US, checked against the live catalogue every day.

What mystery titles were just added to Hulu?

Recent arrivals include Whistle, Jeepers Creepers, Ace Ventura: Pet Detective.

More on Hulu

Mysteries on other services